Skip to Main Navigation Skip to Main Content Skip to Footer
search play2 play3 facebook twitter linkedin2 cross instagram
ASCP
  • DASHBOARD
  • STORE
  • LOGOUT
  • STORE
  • LOGIN
Menu
  • Membership
    • Membership Overview
      • Become a Member
      • Member Testimonials
    • Member Resources
      • My Dashboard
      • Manage My Education
      • Renew My Membership
      • Member Center
      • Find a Mentorship
      • Councils & Committees
      • Volunteer Opportunities
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Member Rewards
      • Lab Week
      • ASCP News
      • ASCP Local Chapters
      • Cell Bowl
    • My Role
      • Pathologist
      • Laboratory Professional
      • Pathology Resident
      • Residency Program Director
      • Lab Sciences Program Director
      • Laboratory Science Student
      • Medical Student
    • Career Resources
      • Find a Job
      • Post a Job
      • Find a Pathology Fellowship
      • Post a Fellowship
      • Learn About Careers
      • Scholarships & Grants
  • Learning
    • Learning Overview
    • Certificate Programs
      • Lab Management University
      • University of Path Informatics
      • Leadership Institute
    • Live Events
      • ASCP Annual Meeting
      • Virtual Pathology Grand Rounds
      • KnowledgeLab
      • Pathology Update
    • Resources
      • Access My Education
      • Manage CMP
      • Manage CC
    • ASCPedia
    • Online Education
      • Online CE Packages
      • LabQ
      • Case Reports
      • Resident Question Bank (RQB)
      • MLS Online Review Course
      • Webcasts
      • Patient Safety
      • Featured Education
    • Quality Improvement & Quality Assurance
      • Continuous Quality Improvement (CQI)
      • National Pathology Quality Registry (NPQR)
      • CheckPath
      • GYN Assessment
      • Non-GYN Assessment
      • GYN Proficiency Testing
    • Books & Journals
      • Books
      • American Journal of Clinical Pathology (AJCP)
      • Lab Medicine
      • Critical Values
    • ACCME ACCREDITATION
  • Advocacy & Outreach
    • Institute For Science Technology, and Public Policy
      • ASCP Policy Efforts
      • Choosing Wisely
      • Guidelines & Resources
      • Workforce Initiatives
      • ePolicy News
    • Center For Global Health
      • Overview
      • Communicable Diseases (HIV)
      • Non-Communicable Diseases (Cancer)
      • Volunteer with CGH
    • ASCP Foundation
      • Make a Donation
      • Providing Scholarships, Grants, & Fellowships
      • Improving Global Health
      • Increasing Lab Visibility
      • ASCP General Fund
      • Ways to Donate
    • Get Involved
      • Discover Opportunities to Get Involved
      • Foster Diversity & Inclusion
      • ASCP Councils & Committees
      • Career Ambassadors
      • Pathology Ambassadors
      • Discover Mentorships
      • Apply to Volunteer
    • Laboratory Excellence
      • Leading Laboratories
      • National Pathology Quality Registry (NPQR)
      • Awards & Recognition
      • Lab Week
    • Patient Champions
  • About ASCP
    • About ASCP
      • ASCP Mission
      • Supporting Our Members
      • ASCP Foundation
      • Community Efforts
      • Work at ASCP
    • Contact Us
  • Board of Certification
    • BOC home
    • About The BOC
      • About the BOC
        • BOC Structure
          • BOC Mission
          • BOC Partners
          • Contact BOC
          • Appeals
        • News and Reports
          • Transition of MT/MLS and MP/MB
          • Newsletters
          • BOC Awards
          • Lab Hero Interviews
          • Statistics / Practice Analyses
      • What We Do
        • Our Services
          • Certs & Quals
          • CMP
          • Verify Credentials
      • Governance
        • Committees
          • Exam Committee
          • Board of Governors
        • International Governance
          • Advisory Boards
          • Collaborating Societies
      • Volunteer
        • Volunteer Opportunities
          • Exam Committees
          • International Volunteer Opportunities
          • ASCP
    • Get Credentialed
      • Certification Exam Process
        • Get Ready to Apply
          • General Information
          • Determine Category & Route
          • Compare US & International Certification
        • Gather Documentation
          • US Certification
          • International Certication
          • US Military
        • Before Exam
          • Schedule a Date
          • Study Materials
        • Exam Day
          • The Test Center
          • The Examination
        • After Exam
          • Pass The Exam
          • Fail The Exam
      • U.S. Certifications
        • Highest Volume
          • Histotechnician, HT(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCP)
          • Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCP)
        • Technician
          • Histotechnician, HT(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Assistant, MLA(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCP)
          • Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCP)
          • Donor Phlebotomy Technician, DPT(ASCP)
        • Technologist/Scientists
          • Technologist in Blood Banking, BB(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Chemistry, C(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Cytogenetics, CG(ASCP)
          • Cytologist, CT(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Hematology, H(ASCP)
          • Histotechnologist, HTL(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Microbiology, M(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCP)
        • Specialist
          • Specialist in Blood Banking, SBB(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Chemistry, SC(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Cytology, SCT(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Cytometry, SCYM(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Hematology, SH(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Microbiology, SM(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Molecular Biology, SMB(ASCP)
        • Additional
          • Diplomate in Laboratory Management, DLM(ASCP)
          • Pathologists’ Assistant, PA(ASCP)
          • Diplomate in Medical Laboratory Immunology, DMLI(ASCP)
      • International Certifications
        • Highest Volume
          • International Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCPi)
          • International Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCPi)
        • Technician
          • International Histotechnician, HT(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCPi)
          • International Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCPi)
        • Technologist/Scientists
          • International Technologist in Blood Banking, BB(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Chemistry, C(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Cytogenetics, CG(ASCPi)
          • Científico de Laboratorio Médico Internacional, CLM(ASCPi)
          • International Cytologist, CT(ASCPi)
          • International Gynecologic Cytologist, CTgyn(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Hematology, H(ASCPi)
          • International Histotechnologist, HTL(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Microbiology, M(ASCPi)
        • Specialist
          • International Specialist in Blood Banking, SBB(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Chemistry, SC(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Cytology, SCT(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Cytometry, SCYM(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Hematology, SH(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Microbiology, SM(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Molecular Biology, SMB(ASCPi)
      • Qualifications
        • Get Ready to Apply
          • General Information
          • Determine Category and Exam Route
          • Gather Document
        • Examination
          • Take the Exam
          • Pass the Exam
          • Fail the Exam
        • Qualifications
          • Qualification in Biorepository Science, QBRS
          • Qualification in Donor Phlebotomy, QDP
          • Qualification in Apheresis, QIA
          • Qualification in Immunohistochemistry, QIHC
          • Qualification in Laboratory Safety, QLS
      • State Licensure
        • California State Licensure
          • California State Licensure Only
          • ASCP Certification & CA Licensure
          • Already ASCP Certified
        • New York State Licensure
          • New York State Licensure Only
          • ASCP Certification & NY Licensure
          • Already ASCP Certified
        • Additional Licensure States
          • Florida
          • Hawaii
          • Louisiana
          • Montana
          • Nevada
          • North Dakota
          • Tennesee
          • West Virginia
          • Puerto Rico
    • Stay Credentialed
      • Information About CMP
        • CMP Overview
          • CMP Process
          • Synchronize Multiple Credentials
        • Credential Status
          • Mandatory
          • Voluntary
          • Expired
          • Inactive
        • How to Manage Points
          • How to Earn Points
          • How to Record Points
          • Suggested CE Providers
          • When to Submit a Declaration
          • COVID Related CE Form
      • U.S. Certifications
        • Highest Volume
          • Histotechnician, HT(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCP)
          • Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCP)
        • Technician
          • Histotechnician, HT(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Assistant, MLA(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCP)
          • Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCP)
          • Apheresis Technician, AT(ASCP)
          • Donor Phlebotomy Technician, DPT(ASCP)
        • Technologist/Scientists
          • Technologist in Blood Banking, BB(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Chemistry, C(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Cytogenetics, CG(ASCP)
          • Cytologist, CT(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Hematology, H(ASCP)
          • Histotechnologist, HTL(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Microbiology, M(ASCP)
          • Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCP)
          • Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCP)
        • Specialist
          • Specialist in Blood Banking, SBB(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Chemistry, SC(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Cytology, SCT(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Cytometry, SCYM(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Hematology, SH(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Microbiology, SM(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Molecular Biology, SMB(ASCP)
          • Hemapheresis Practioner, HP(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Laboratory Safety, SLS(ASCP)
          • Specialist in Virology, SV(ASCP)
        • Additional
          • Diplomate in Laboratory Management, DLM(ASCP)
          • Pathologists’ Assistant, PA(ASCP)
      • International Certifications
        • Highest Volume
          • International Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCPi)
          • International Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCPi)
        • Technician
          • International Histotechnician, HT(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Technician, MLT(ASCPi)
          • International Phlebotomy Technician, PBT(ASCPi)
        • Technologist/Scientists
          • International Technologist in Blood Banking, BB(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Chemistry, C(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Cytogenetics, CG(ASCPi)
          • Científico de Laboratorio Médico Internacional, CLM(ASCPi)
          • International Cytologist, CT(ASCPi)
          • International Gynecologic Cytologist, CTgyn(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Hematology, H(ASCPi)
          • International Histotechnologist, HTL(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Microbiology, M(ASCPi)
          • International Technologist in Molecular Biology, MB(ASCPi)
          • International Medical Laboratory Scientist, MLS(ASCPi)
        • Specialist
          • International Specialist in Blood Banking, SBB(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Chemistry, SC(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Cytology, SCT(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Cytometry, SCYM(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Hematology, SH(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Microbiology, SM(ASCPi)
          • International Specialist in Molecular Biology, SMB(ASCPi)
      • Qualifications
        • Qualifications
          • Qualification in Biorepository Science, QBRS
          • Qualification in Donor Phlebotomy, QDP
          • Qualification in Apheresis, QIA
          • Qualification in Immunohistochemistry, QIHC
          • Qualification in Lab Informatics, QLI
          • Qualification in Laboratory Safety, QLS
    • Verify Credentials
      • General Information
        • Topics
          • Citation of Credentials
          • Fraudulent Use of Credentials
          • Replacement Wall Certificates
      • How to Verify
        • Options for Verifying Credentials
          • Getting Started
          • For Certification/Qualification
          • For State Licensure
          • For Visa Screen
          • Place an Order
    • Program Directors
      • Program Director Resources
        • Resources
          • BOC Resources
          • Accreditation Agencies
      • Manage Your Students
        • Tools & Reports
          • Tools for Students
          • EEV
          • PPR
      • Certification Information
        • Exams Offered
          • Certification Exams
          • HT/HTL
          • Military Certifications
          • Phlebotomy Programs
  • News
  • News
  • News Archive
  • Groups
  • Jobs
  • ASCP
  • News Archive
  • News Detail

On Antigen Testing for COVID-19

Publication Date: Nov 11, 2020

By Gary W. Procop, MD, MS

The performance of antigen testing in microbiology is well understood as there is abundant literature and years of experience.  The principles, advantages and limitations that have been described for Group A Streptococcus, respiratory viral antigen testing, and other antigen tests for infectious agents hold true for antigen tests for COVID-19.  Critical to the performance and positive predictive value of these or any tests are the analytic test performance characteristics of the test (i.e. sensitivity & specificity) and the population that is being tested.  These factors are clear to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, which acknowledged in a response letter to an ASCP recommendation that “test setting and patient population play an important role in determining test performance.”  FDA added that these factors are considered “when reviewing an Emergency Use Authorization request…”

Antigen tests for respiratory viral pathogens are less sensitive than reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) assays.  Unfortunately, the limits of detection (LoD) of antigen tests are not included in the FDA webpage that compares the LoD of numerous molecular SARS-CoV-2 assays (https://www.fda.gov/medical-devices/coronavirus-covid-19-and-medical-devices/sars-cov-2-reference-panel-comparative-data).  The FDA should include the LoD of these assays for comparative purposes and as a public service to patients and providers alike.

Optimal Use of Antigen Test: True Positives

Antigen tests are most useful to confirm a clinically suspected infections (i.e. a symptomatic patient).  The positive predictive value (i.e. the likelihood that a positive test result is a true positive) is high when the test is used in this setting.  Additional advantages include, ease of test performance, a quick time to diagnosis and a low cost.

Challenge #1: False Negatives

When the antigen test is negative on a symptomatic patient (i.e. a test result/clinical mismatch), then the patient should be retested with an RT-PCR assay.  Occasional false-negative test results are expected to occur due to the limited sensitivity of antigen tests compared with RT-PCR.

This recommendation is consistent with CDC guidance which has stated: “…it may be necessary to confirm a rapid antigen test result with a nucleic acid test, especially if the result of the antigen test is inconsistent with the clinical context (https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/testing-overview.html).”  Otherwise stated:  If there is a mismatch between the clinical findings and the test result, then an RT-PCR should be performed.

Challenge #2: False Positives

As FDA staff noted during an October 7 FDA Town Hall “it is important to consider the positive predictive value when assessing how to react to a positive result.”  Whenever a test is used in a low prevalence setting then the likelihood of false positives increases (See example, below).  This includes using the test for screening asymptomatic patients.  If an asymptomatic patient tests positive with and antigen detection test, there is a significant probability that the test is a false positive, so the presence of SARS-CoV-2 should be confirmed with an RT-PCR test.  There are numerous examples of false positive SARS-CoV-2 antigen tests in the lay press.

This recommendation, again, is consistent with CDC guidance which has stated: “…it may be necessary to confirm a rapid antigen test result with a nucleic acid test, especially if the result of the antigen test is inconsistent with the clinical context (https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/testing-overview.html).”  Otherwise stated:  If there is a clinical/test result mismatch, then an RT-PCR should be performed

There is a significant patient safety issue if these tests are used to cohort patients prior to RT-PCR confirmation, since uninfected patients with false-positives results would be placed in close proximity with patient who are infected, and thereby may become infected themselves.  If antigen tests are used to screen asymptomatic patients, then positive results should be considered presumptive positives, until confirmed by an RT-PCR test.  These patients could be kept in isolation, but should not be cohorted with other patients with COVID-19, until infection is confirmed.

There is also a danger of artificially inflated infection rates if positive results from asymptomatic patients are reported with RT-PCR confirmation.

Example:

This table is an excerpt from the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute report GP49, Developing and Managing a Medical Laboratory (Test) Utilization Management Program.  It demonstrates how the positive predictive value (i.e. the likelihood that a positive test result represents actual disease in the patient) of a very good test (i.e. 95% sensitivity/95% specificity) diminishes from 95% when there is a prevalence of 50% to 16% when the prevalence is 1%.  Otherwise stated:  At a prevalence of 1%, only 16 out of 100 positive results are correct, the remainder (84 out of 100) are wrong (i.e. false positives)!

Gary W. Procop, MD, MS, MASCP, is a member of the ASCP Board of Directors and also Chair of the ASCP Institute for Science, Technology and Public Policy. He is the director of Molecular Microbiology, Mycology, Parasitology and Virology Laboratories at the Cleveland Clinic, where he is also The Belinda Yen-Lieberman, PhD & James M. Lieberman, MD Endowed Chair in Clinical Microbiology.

Footer
  • Membership
    • Membership Overview
    • Member Resources
    • My Role
    • Career Resources
  • Learning
    • Online Education
    • Certificate Programs
    • Quality Improvement & Quality Assurance
    • Live Events
    • Books & Journals
    • Resources
    • ASCPedia
    • ACCME Accreditation
    • Featured Education
  • Advocacy & Outreach
    • Institute for Science, Technology, and Public Policy
    • Center for Global Health
    • ASCP Foundation
    • Patient Champions
    • Get Involved
  • About ASCP
    • Contact Us
    • Chat with Us
  • Board Of Certification
    • Get Credentialed
    • Stay Credentialed
    • Verify Credentials
    • Program Directors
    • About the BOC
  • News
    • ePolicy News
Chicago (Headquarters)
33 West Monroe Street, Suite 1600, Chicago, IL 60603

Privacy Policy 

Terms of Use

Follow Us

Copyright ©2021  by American Society for Clinical Pathology. All Rights Reserved.

Live Chat

First Name*
Last Name*
Email*
Customer ID